First, you can make a paste that is diluted white glue and warm water. Basically, you use two parts white glue with one part warm water. Put the glue and water into a plastic bowl. Add more water, while stirring the mixture, until you get a soupy mixture. The final product should be watery yet still have a slight white glue consistency.
Second, you can create a flour paste to use as Plaster of Paris. Use two to three cups of white flour with one cup to two cups of warm water. Mix the flour and water in a plastic bowl until there are no lumps, and the consistency is a smooth paste that’s easy to stir.
It’s recommended that you use the above recipes with strips of newspaper or gauze strips
This is the best I can come up with without actually buying plaster of paris powder.
Why not just buy the mixable powder...?
It is inexpensive and easy.
www.dickblick.com has several to chose from.